824“‘Only here is there purity’ —that’s what they say—Idheva suddhī iti vādayanti,
‘No other doctrines are pure’
—so they say.Nāññesu dhammesu visuddhimāhu;
Insisting that what they depend on is good,Yaṁ nissitā tattha subhaṁ vadānā,
they are deeply entrenched
in idiosyncratic truths.Paccekasaccesu puthū niviṭṭhā.1 825Seeking controversy, they plunge into an assembly,Te vādakāmā parisaṁ vigayha, regarding one another as fools.Bālaṁ dahantī mithu aññamaññaṁ;
Relying on others’ authority,
they speak in debate.Vadanti te aññasitā kathojjaṁ,
Desiring praise, they claim to be skilled.Pasaṁsakāmā kusalā vadānā.
826Engaged in disputes in the midst of the assembly,Yutto kathāyaṁ parisāya majjhe, —anxious, desiring praise—Pasaṁsamicchaṁ vinighāti hoti;
the one defeated is
chagrined.Apāhatasmiṁ pana maṅku hoti,
Shaken with criticism, he seeks for an opening.Nindāya so kuppati randhamesī.
827He whose doctrine is [judged as] demolished,Yamassa vādaṁ parihīnamāhu, defeated, by those judging the issue:Apāhataṁ pañhavimaṁsakāse;
He laments, he grieves—the inferior exponent.Paridevati socati hīnavādo,
‘He beat me,’ he mourns.Upaccagā manti anutthunāti.
828These disputes have arisen among contemplatives.Ete vivādā samaṇesu jātā, In them are
elation,
dejection.Etesu ugghātinighāti hoti;
Seeing this, one should abstain from disputes,Etampi disvā virame kathojjaṁ,
for they have no other goal
than the gaining of praise.Na haññadatthatthi pasaṁsalābhā.
829While he who is praised therePasaṁsito vā pana tattha hoti, for expounding his doctrine
in the midst of the assembly,Akkhāya vādaṁ parisāya majjhe;
laughs on that account & grows haughty,So hassatī unnamatī ca tena,
attaining his heart’s desire.Pappuyya tamatthaṁ yathā mano ahu.
830That haughtiness will be grounds for his damage,Yā unnatī sāssa vighātabhūmi, for he’ll speak in pride & conceit.Mānātimānaṁ vadate paneso;
Seeing this, one should abstain from debates.Etampi disvā na vivādayetha,
No purity is attained by them, say the skilled.Na hi tena suddhiṁ kusalā vadanti.
831Like a strong man nourished on royal food,Sūro yathā rājakhādāya puṭṭho, you prowl about, roaring, searching out an opponent.Abhigajjameti paṭisūramicchaṁ;
Wherever the battle is,
go there, strong man.Yeneva so tena palehi sūra, … yadidaṁ yudhāya.
As before, there’s none here.Pubbeva natthi
832Those who dispute, taking hold of a view,Ye diṭṭhimuggayha vivādayanti, saying, “This, and this only, is true,”Idameva saccanti ca vādayanti;
those you can talk to.Te tvaṁ vadassū
Here there is nothing—
no confrontation
at the birth of disputes.na hi tedha atthi, Vādamhi jāte paṭisenikattā.2 833Whom would you gain as opponent, Pasūra,Tesu tvaṁ kiṁ labhetho pasūra, among those who live above confrontation—Visenikatvā pana ye caranti,
not pitting view against view—Diṭṭhīhi diṭṭhiṁ avirujjhamānā;
who have nothing here grasped as supreme?Yesīdha natthī paramuggahītaṁ.
conjecturing,Atha tvaṁ pavitakkamāgamā,
your mind thinking up
viewpoints.Manasā diṭṭhigatāni cintayanto;
You’re paired off with a pure oneDhonena yugaṁ samāgamā,
and so cannot proceed.”Na hi tvaṁ sakkhasi sampayātaveti.
Translator’s notes
1. Pacceka-sacca. The word pacceka can also mean singular, personal, or individual. AN 10:20 lists the following views as idiosyncratic truths. “The cosmos is eternal,” “The cosmos is not eternal,” “The cosmos is finite,” “The cosmos is infinite,” “The soul & the body are the same,” “The soul is one thing & the body another,” “After death a Tathāgata exists,” “After death a Tathāgata does not exist,” “After death a Tathāgata both does & does not exist,” “After death a Tathāgata neither does nor does not exist.” These truths are distinct from noble truths, in that the word for “noble”—ariya—can also mean “universal.”
2. See AN 10:93.
On the Buddha as a debater, see Skill in Questions, chapter 5.