895“Those who, dwelling on views,“Ye kecime diṭṭhiparibbasānā, dispute, saying, ‘Only this is true’:Idameva saccanti vivādayanti;
Do they all incur blame,Sabbeva te nindamanvānayanti,
or also earn praise there?”Atho pasaṁsampi labhanti tattha”.
896“[The praise:] It’s such a small thing, not at all appeasing.“Appañhi etaṁ na alaṁ samāya,1 I speak of two fruits of dispute;Duve vivādassa phalāni brūmi;
and seeing this, you shouldn’t dispute—Etampi disvā na vivādayetha,
seeing the state
where there’s no dispute
as secure.Khemābhipassaṁ avivādabhūmiṁ”.
doesn’t enter into
any conventions
born of the run-of-the mill
at all.“Yā kācimā sammutiyo puthujjā,
Sabbāva etā na upeti vidvā;
One who’s uninvolved:Anūpayo so
When he’s forming no predilection
for what’s seen, for what’s heard,Diṭṭhe sute khantimakubbamāno”.
why would he get
involved?upayaṁ kimeyya,2 are ultimate
say that purity’s
a matter of self-restraint.“Sīluttamā saññamenāhu suddhiṁ,
Undertaking a practice,
they devote themselves to it:Vataṁ samādāya upaṭṭhitāse;
‘Let’s train just in this,
and then there would be purity.’Idheva sikkhema athassa suddhiṁ,
Those who say they are skilled
are [thus] led on to becoming.Bhavūpanītā kusalāvadānā.
899But if one of them falls from his habits or practice,Sace cuto sīlavatato hoti,
he trembles,
having failed in his actions.Pavedhatī kamma virādhayitvā;
He hopes for, longs for, purity,Pajappatī patthayatī ca suddhiṁ,
like a caravan leader lost
far from home.Satthāva hīno pavasaṁ gharamhā.
900But one who’s abandoned —all—Sīlabbataṁ vāpi pahāya sabbaṁ,
things that are blamable, blameless,Kammañca sāvajjanavajjametaṁ;4 not hoping for ‘pure’ or ‘impure,’Suddhiṁ asuddhinti apatthayāno,5 would live in kindness & peace,
without taking up peace,6 detached.Virato care santimanuggahāya.
on taboos, austerities,Tamūpanissāya jigucchitaṁ vā,
or what’s seen, heard, or sensed,Atha vāpi diṭṭhaṁ va sutaṁ mutaṁ vā;
they speak of purity
through wandering further on
through becoming & not-,Uddhaṁsarā suddhimanutthunanti, … bhavābhavesu.
their craving not gone
for becoming & not-.Avītataṇhāse bhavābhavesu.7 902For one who aspires has longingsPatthayamānassa hi jappitāni, & trembling with regard to theorizings.Pavedhitaṁ vāpi pakappitesu;
But one who here
has no passing away & arising:Cutūpapāto idha yassa natthi,
Why would he tremble?
For what would he long?”Sa kena vedheyya kuhiṁ va jappe”.
903“The teaching some say is ‘supreme,’“Yamāhu dhammaṁ paramanti eke, is the very one others call ‘lowly.’Tameva hīnanti panāhu aññe;
Which statement is trueSacco nu vādo katamo imesaṁ,
when all of these claim to be skilled?”Sabbeva hīme kusalāvadānā”.
904“They say their own teaching is perfect“Sakañhi dhammaṁ paripuṇṇamāhu, while the doctrine of others is lowly.Aññassa dhammaṁ pana hīnamāhu;
Thus quarreling, they dispute,Evampi viggayha vivādayanti,
each saying his agreed-on opinion
is true.Sakaṁ sakaṁ sammutimāhu saccaṁ.
905If something, because of an opponent’s say-so, were lowly,Parassa ce vambhayitena hīno,
then none among teachings would be
superlative,Na koci dhammesu visesi assa;
for many say
that another’s teaching’s inferiorPuthū hi aññassa vadanti dhammaṁ, Nihīnato
when firmly asserting their own.samhi daḷhaṁ vadānā.
906If their worship of their teaching were true,Saddhammapūjāpi nesaṁ tatheva, in line with the way they praise their own path,Yathā pasaṁsanti sakāyanāni;
then all doctrines
would be true—Sabbeva vādā tathiyā bhaveyyuṁ,
for purity’s theirs, according to each.Suddhī hi nesaṁ paccattameva.
907The brahman has nothing led by another,Na brāhmaṇassa paraneyyamatthi,
when considering what’s grasped
among doctrines.Dhammesu niccheyya samuggahītaṁ;
Thus he has gone
beyond disputes,Tasmā vivādāni upātivatto,
for he doesn’t regard as best
the knowledge of a doctrine,
any other doctrine.Na hi seṭṭhato passati dhammamaññaṁ.8 908‘I know. I see. That’s just how it is!’—Jānāmi passāmi tatheva etaṁ, Some believe purity’s in terms of view.Diṭṭhiyā eke paccenti suddhiṁ;
But even if a person has seen,
what good does it do him?Addakkhi ce kiñhi tumassa tena,
Having slipped past,
they speak of purity
in connection with something
or somebody else.Atisitvā aññena vadanti suddhiṁ.
sees name-&-form.Passaṁ naro dakkhati nāmarūpaṁ,
Having seen, he’ll know
only these things.Disvāna vā ñassati tānimeva;
No matter if he’s seen little, a lot,Kāmaṁ bahuṁ passatu appakaṁ vā,
the skilled don’t say purity’s
in connection with that.Na hi tena suddhiṁ kusalā vadanti.
910A person entrenched in his teachings, preferring a theorized view,
isn’t easy to discipline.Nivissavādī na hi subbināyo,
Pakappitaṁ diṭṭhi purakkharāno;
Whatever he depends on
he describes it as lovely,Yaṁ nissito tattha subhaṁ vadāno,
says that it’s purity,
that there he saw truth.Suddhiṁ vado tattha tathaddasā so.
911The brahman, evaluating, doesn’t enter into a theory,Na brāhmaṇo kappamupeti saṅkhā,
doesn’t follow views,
isn’t tied even to knowledge.Na diṭṭhisārī napi ñāṇabandhu;9 And on knowing
whatever’s conventional, commonplace,Ñatvā ca so sammutiyo puthujjā,
he remains equanimous:
‘That’s what others hold onto.’Upekkhatī uggahaṇanti maññe.
912Having untied the knots here in the world,Vissajja ganthāni … idha loke,
the sage here in the world10 doesn’t follow a faction
when disputes have arisen.munīdha loke, Vivādajātesu na vaggasārī;
At peace among those not at peace,
he’s equanimous, doesn’t hold on:
‘That’s what others hold onto.’Santo asantesu upekkhako so,
Anuggaho uggahaṇanti maññe.
913Giving up old effluents, not forming new,Pubbāsave hitvā nave akubbaṁ,
neither pursuing desire,
nor entrenched in his teachings,Na chandagū nopi nivissavādī;
he’s totally released
from viewpoints,
enlightened.Sa vippamutto diṭṭhigatehi dhīro,
He doesn’t adhere to the world,
is without self-rebuke;Na lippati loke anattagarahī.
with regard to all thingsSa sabbadhammesu visenibhūto,
seen, heard, or sensed.Yaṁ kiñci diṭṭhaṁ va sutaṁ mutaṁ vā;
His burden laid down,
the sage totally releasedSa pannabhāro muni vippamutto,
is improper :: is theory-freeNa kappiyo
hasn’t stopped :: isn’t impassionednūparato
isn’t worth wanting :: doesn’t
desire,”na patthiyo”ti.12 Translator’s notes
1. Or: Not enough to appease (the defilements, says Nd I).
2. A Sanskrit version of this verse is quoted by Asaṅga in the Bodhisattvabhūmi (48.24).
3. Nd I: Abandoning habits & practices in the sense of no longer believing that purity is measured in terms of them, the view discussed in the preceding verse. See MN 79.
4. Nd I: “Blamable, blameless” = black and white kamma (see AN 4:232, 234, 237–238, quoted in The Wings to Awakening, section I/B.
5. Nd I: Having abandoned impure mental qualities, and having fully attained the goal, the arahant has no need to hope for anything at all.
6. “In kindness & peace, without taking up peace”—a pun on the word, santimanuggahaya.
7. The word bhavabhavesu—”through/for becoming & not-becoming”—functions here as a lamp.
8. “The knowledge of a doctrine, any other doctrine”—a pun on the word, dhammamaññam. Nd I favors the second interpretation, saying that the brahman does not see as best any doctrine aside from the Wings to Awakening: the establishings of mindfulness, the exertions, the bases of power, the faculties, the strengths, the factors for awakening, and the noble eightfold path. This reading seems unlikely, though, as these doctrines are not mentioned anywhere in this poem. The first reading is more in line with the Buddha’s statement in Sn 4:9 that the highest state is not defined in terms of knowledge, and is well-illustrated in action in AN 10:93.
9. According to Nd I, this compound—ñāṇa-bandhu—should be translated as “tied by means of knowledge,” in that the arahant doesn’t use the knowledge that comes with the mastery of concentration, the five mundane forms of psychic power (abhiñña), or any wrong knowledge to create the bonds of craving or views. However, the compound may also refer to the fact that the arahant isn’t tied even to the knowledge that forms part of the path to arahantship (see MN 117).
10. “In the world” functions as a lamp here.
11. See Sn 4:4, note 9.
12. “Is improper :: is free from theories, hasn’t stopped :: isn’t impassioned, isn’t worth wanting :: doesn’t desire”—a series of puns—na kappiyo, nuparato, na patthiyo—each with a strongly positive and a strongly negative meaning, probably meant for their shock value. For a similar set of puns, see Dhp 97.