862“From where have there arisen quarrels, disputes,“Kutopahūtā kalahā vivādā,
lamentation, sorrows, along with stinginess,Paridevasokā sahamaccharā ca;
conceit & pride, along with divisiveness?Mānātimānā sahapesuṇā ca,
From where have they arisen?
Please tell me.”Kutopahūtā te tadiṅgha brūhi”.
there have arisen
quarrels, disputes,“Piyappahūtā kalahā vivādā,
lamentation, sorrows, along with stinginess,Paridevasokā sahamaccharā ca;
conceit & pride, along with divisiveness.Mānātimānā sahapesuṇā ca,
Tied up with stinginess
are quarrels & disputes.Maccherayuttā kalahā vivādā;
In the arising of disputes
is divisiveness.”Vivādajātesu ca pesuṇāni”.
of things dear in the world,“Piyā su lokasmiṁ kutonidānā,
along with the greeds that go about in the world?Ye cāpi lobhā vicaranti loke;
And where is the cause
of the hopes & aimsĀsā ca niṭṭhā ca kutonidānā,
for the sake of a person’s next life?”Ye samparāyāya narassa honti”.
865“Desires are the cause of things dear in the world,“Chandānidānāni piyāni loke,
along with the greeds that go about in the world.Ye cāpi lobhā vicaranti loke;
And here too is the cause
of the hopes & aimsĀsā ca niṭṭhā ca itonidānā,
for the sake of a person’s next life.”Ye samparāyāya narassa honti”.
866“Now where is the cause of desire in the world?“Chando nu lokasmiṁ kutonidāno,
And from where have there arisen
decisions, anger, lies, & perplexity,Vinicchayā cāpi kutopahūtā;
Kodho mosavajjañca kathaṅkathā ca,
and all the qualities
described by the Contemplative?”Ye vāpi dhammā samaṇena vuttā”.
‘appealing’ &
‘unappealing’
in the world:“Sātaṁ asātanti yamāhu loke,
In dependence on that,
desire arises.Tamūpanissāya pahoti chando;
Having seen becoming & not-
with regard to forms,Rūpesu disvā vibhavaṁ bhavañca,
a person gives rise to decisions in the world;Vinicchayaṁ kubbati jantu loke.
868anger, lies, & perplexity:Kodho mosavajjañca kathaṅkathā ca, these qualities, too,
when there exists
that very pair.Etepi dhammā dvayameva sante;
A person perplexed
should train for the path of knowledge,Kathaṅkathī ñāṇapathāya sikkhe,
for it’s in having known
that the Contemplative has spoken
of qualities/dhammas.”Ñatvā pavuttā samaṇena dhammā”.1 of appealing & un-?“Sātaṁ asātañca kutonidānā,
When what isn’t
do they not exist?Kismiṁ asante na bhavanti hete;
And whatever is meant
by becoming & not- :Vibhavaṁ bhavañcāpi yametamatthaṁ,
Tell me,
Where is their cause?”Etaṁ me pabrūhi yatonidānaṁ”.
of appealing & un-.“Phassanidānaṁ sātaṁ asātaṁ,
When contact isn’t,
they do not exist,Phasse asante na bhavanti hete;
along with what’s meant
by becoming & not- :Vibhavaṁ bhavañcāpi yametamatthaṁ,
I tell you,
from here is their cause.”Etaṁ te pabrūmi itonidānaṁ”.
871“Now where is the cause of contact in the world,“Phasso nu lokasmi kutonidāno,
and from where have graspings,
possessions, arisen?Pariggahā cāpi kutopahūtā;
When what isn’t
does there not exist mine-ness?Kismiṁ asante na mamattamatthi,
When what has disappeared
do contacts not touch?”Kismiṁ vibhūte na phusanti phassā”.
872“Conditioned by name-&-form is contact.“Nāmañca rūpañca paṭicca phasso,
In longing do graspings,
possessions have their cause.Icchānidānāni pariggahāni;
When longing isn’t,
mine-ness doesn’t exist.Icchāyasantyā na mamattamatthi,
When forms have disappeared
contacts don’t touch.”Rūpe vibhūte na phusanti phassā”.
does form disappear?“Kathaṁ sametassa vibhoti rūpaṁ,
How do pleasure & pain disappear?Sukhaṁ dukhañcāpi kathaṁ vibhoti;
Tell me this.Etaṁ me pabrūhi
My heart is set
on knowing how
they disappear.”yathā vibhoti, Taṁ jāniyāmāti me mano ahu”.
874“One not percipient of perceptions“Na saññasaññī not percipient of aberrant perceptions,na visaññasaññī,
not unpercipient,Nopi asaññī
nor percipient of what’s disappeared2:na vibhūtasaññī; For one thus-arriving,
form disappears3—Evaṁ sametassa vibhoti rūpaṁ, for objectification-classifications4 have their cause in perception.”Saññānidānā hi papañcasaṅkhā”.
you’ve expounded to us.“Yaṁ taṁ apucchimha akittayī no,
We ask one thing more.
Please tell it.Aññaṁ taṁ pucchāma tadiṅgha brūhi;
Do some of the wise
say that just this much is the utmost,
that purity of spirit5 is here?Ettāvataggaṁ nu vadanti heke,
Yakkhassa suddhiṁ idha paṇḍitāse; Or do they say
that it’s other than this?”Udāhu aññampi vadanti etto”.
say that just this much is the utmost,
that purity of spirit is here.“Ettāvataggampi vadanti heke,
Yakkhassa suddhiṁ idha paṇḍitāse;
But some of them,
who say they are skilled,
say it’s the moment
with no clinging remaining.Tesaṁ paneke samayaṁ vadanti,
Anupādisese kusalā vadānā.
‘Having known, they still are dependent,’Ete ca ñatvā upanissitāti,6 the sage ponders dependencies.Ñatvā munī nissaye so vimaṁsī;
On knowing them, released,
he doesn’t get into disputes,Ñatvā vimutto na vivādameti,
doesn’t meet with becoming & not-
: He’s enlightened.”Bhavābhavāya na sameti dhīro”ti.
Translator’s notes
1. As other passages in this poem indicate (see note 6, below), the goal is not measured in terms of knowledge, but as this passage points out, knowledge is a necessary part of the path to the goal.
2. According to Nd I, “percipient of perceptions” means having ordinary perceptions. “Percipient of aberrant perceptions” means being insane. “Unpercipient” means either having entered the cessation of perception and feeling (see AN 9:33) or the dimension of beings without perception (DN 1 and DN 15). “Percipient of what’s disappeared” (or: having perceptions that have disappeared) means having entered any of the four formless states. Of these four explanations, the last is the least likely, for as the next lines show, this passage is describing the stage of concentration practice in which one is transcending the fourth jhāna and entering the formless attainment of the infinitude of space. A more likely explanation of “percipient of what’s disappeared” would be the act of holding to perceptions of the breath and of pleasure and pain, even though these phenomena have all disappeared in the fourth jhāna (see SN 36:11, AN 9:31, AN 10:20, and AN 10:72).
3. This is the point where the meditator leaves the fourth jhāna and enters the perception of the infinitude of space.
4. Objectification-classifications (papañca-saṅkhā): Nd I defines papañca simply as craving, views, and conceit. A survey of how the term papañca is actually used in the suttas, however, shows that it denotes the mind’s tendency to objectify itself as a being. Then, from that objectification, it searches for nourishment to keep that being in existence, classifying experience in terms conducive to that search and thus giving rise to conflict. As Sn 4:14 points out, the root of the objectification-classifications is the perception, “I am the thinker.” For further discussion of this point, see note 1 to that sutta and the introduction to MN 18.
5. “Spirit” is the usual rendering of the Pali word, yakkha. According to Nd I, however, in this context the word yakkha means person, individual, human being, or living being.
6. In other words, the sage knows that both groups in the previous verse fall back on their knowledge as a measure of the goal, without comprehending the dependency still latent in their knowledge. The sages in the first group are mistaking the experience of neither perception nor non-perception as the goal, and so they are still dependent on that state of concentration. The sages in the second group, by the fact that they claim to be skilled, show that there is still a latent conceit in their experience of not-clinging, and thus it is not totally independent of clinging. (For more on this point, see MN 102.) Both groups still maintain the concept of a “spirit” that is purified in the realization of purity. Once these dependencies are comprehended, one gains release from disputes and from states of becoming and not-becoming. It is in this way that knowledge is a means to the goal, but the goal itself is not measured or defined in terms of knowledge.